PEN/Hemingway Award for Debut Novel 2025, Longlist
It鈥檚 1970, and on the Windy Creek Reservation in South Dakota, amidst the rise of AIM in neighboring Pine Ridge, a baby boy appears nestled in a box of Styrofoam peanuts on the doorstep of St. Rose Catholic Church. His appearance disrupts the predictable, lonely life of longtime reservation priest Father Joe Kreitzer. The child, whom they name Bear, finds refuge under the care of Father Joe鈥檚 closest friend and ally, Alice Nighthawk.
Thirteen years pass without event, when Alice鈥檚 older son, Albert, is mysteriously murdered outside a bar in Rapid City, and Bear is accused of attempting to kill the only person who knows what happened that night. At the same time, Father Joe receives a letter from a person from his past, the only woman who made him question the path of priesthood. She has reached out to Father Joe as one of the few who might help her.
To keep Bear鈥檚 case from federal prosecution, Father Joe and Alice begin a search for Bear鈥檚 long-lost mother. But their journey unearths more than they bargained for, plunging Father Joe into a labyrinth of secrets and revelations. He is forced not only to confront the choices he鈥檚 made and the secrets he keeps, but also to see the truth of the lives of the people around him.
High Hawk is a rich tapestry of love and history, delving into the delicate intricacies of the past and the redemptive power of second chances. Through evocative prose, the lives of those on the fringes of American culture come alive, navigating adversity and forging connections against all odds.
鈥High Hawk is evocative and haunting. I didn鈥檛 want to put it down, despite the loneliness of it鈥攁 kind of beautiful, desolate, at times cold and very snowy loneliness, windblown and stark. Light and sky figure heavily, the horizon and a longing for some kind of place in the order of things. For connection, truth, but most of all for a way of belonging in the world. There鈥檚 a sense of the complexity of life but also of it getting away from you; of looking back at moments you let pass you by. It is a beautiful meditation on silence and speaking, passivity and action; and on parents, and love, and the fragility of our ability to protect our children鈥攖he way that鈥檚 amplified in some communities鈥 lives by compounding circumstances. High Hawk leaves us with no easy answers, but feeling as though we鈥檝e just listened to a keening, plaintive song that carries over the prairie as dusk falls.鈥濃擜rianne Zwartjes, author, These Dark Skies, Reckoning with Identity, Violence, and Power from Abroad
"In High Hawk, author Amy Frykholm delivers a beautiful blend of the simple and the profound in a story of self-discovery and reckoning. The gorgeously-rendered small-town Midwest setting and nuanced characters are a perfect fit for fans of William Kent Krueger."鈥擜my Pease, author, Northwoods
"High Hawk is, at one of its hearts, a tale of two improbable love stories鈥攐ne between a mother and son and another between two long separated friends. Spare and lyrical, Amy Frykholm somehow conjures entire worlds鈥攂oth interior and exterior鈥攆rom a few dozen words. The landscape she lays out in front of us holds deep meaning and heartbreaking secrets. The exquisitely constructed ending is one of the most poignant and satisfying I have read in years.鈥濃擟ara Wall, author, The Dearly Beloved, a Read with Jenna pick
鈥High Hawk starts out small, quiet, stark鈥攚ith a child left on the doorstep of a Catholic priest on a South Dakota reservation in 1970鈥攂ut then, with a grace as delicate and as natural as a feather, it rises above its specific place, its specific time, and soars over a windy liminal landscape, becoming a universal story of faith and free will, of community and authority, of different kinds of love, and of difficult moral choices: when to obey and when to break away, when to punish and when to forgive, when to reveal the truth and when to keep the silence. And the silence is not the same silence, for some silences corrupt and others heal, and the choices are rarely black and white鈥攜et always the choices matter. The subtle compassion of the narrative put me in mind of the classic by Georges Bernanos, The Diary of a Country Priest, but Frykholm鈥檚 voice is all her own. Read it, and it will linger in your mind for days.鈥濃擮lga Grushin, author, Forty Rooms
鈥High Hawk, like any good novel, mirrors the complexity of real life. . .Frykholm offers a slight flicker of hope鈥攐f repentance, of honesty鈥攁 tiny light wavering amid the gathering darkness.鈥濃Notre Dame Magazine
鈥淔rykholm refuses to deliver a fantasy narrative in which mysteries are resolved and our tarnished heroes redeemed. . .[Father Joe and Alice] don鈥檛 find what they鈥檝e been looking for, but they find something else, something that offers the possibility of wonder, perhaps even grace, in the bleakest of lives. . .The novel鈥檚 satisfying conclusion is a testament to the power of that kind of love, a selfless love for the things that are too sacred.鈥鈥擟olorado Review
鈥淔rykholm offers a satisfying mystery. . .and explores universal themes in less familiar territory: Belonging. Justice. Vocation. Family. . .High Hawk weaves these compelling themes through a narrative that is, at its core, about loneliness and love, the belonging of family and chosen family, and the grace of God that weaves it all together.鈥濃The Presbyterian Outlook
鈥淎 story of depth and delicacy. . . . The writing is excellent; likewise, the pacing, narration, characters, the unfolding mystery. I enjoyed every moment of reading it, especially the profound insight into indigenous culture.鈥濃擬aryanne Hannan, Englewood Review of Books
鈥. . . an evocative, compelling story that boldly explores the harms done by systems and institutions, often in the name of protecting the vulnerable. . . . a powerful exploration of love, belonging, the connection we have to every living being, and the moral duty we have to others鈥攅specially the vulnerable who need our care. In other words, High Hawk is the perfect novel for such a time as ours.鈥濃擬elanie Springer Mock, Current Magazine